Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Nov 14, 2025

more than a whiff of farce

 The opening acts of Latude's Bastille story carry more than a whiff of farce. After serving as a surgeon and barber in the army (the two professions being interchangeable at the time), he came to Paris in 1748, and devised a hare-brained scheme to find fortune and favour among the royal court. His plan was to foil an assassination plot against the king's mistress, the Marquise de Pompadour. A noble cause, perhaps. Except that Latude had manufactured the plot himself after overhearing two men criticising the Marquise while walking in the garden of the Tuileries. He sent a poison letter (in fact containing a harmless powder) to his mark, and then obtained an audience with her at Versailles to warn her of the danger. Before he could leave, however, he was tricked into providing a sample of his own handwriting. When this was compared to the script on the letter, it was immediately clear that saviour and conspirator were one. 

Within days Latude was making his first acquaintance with the Bastille. After a few months, he was transferred to the prison of Vincennes. He duly escaped, making his way through fields and vineyards to a safe-house in Paris. From there, he wrote to the king for clemency - including on his memorandum a return address. Latude was back in the Bastille in a matter of hours. 

- from Fallen Glory, James Crawford, 353

They are clearly starving me to death here

 In fact conditions for many of the Bastille's inmates were markedly better than in most other prisons of the time, and indeed their relative luxury may surprise our modern sensibilities. By the time of Louis XVI, the majority of prisoners were held in spacious, sixteen-foot-wide octagonal cells, positioned in the middle levels of the fortress towers. Each cell had a four-poster bed lined with green curtains, as well as tables, chairs, a stove and a chimney. In the case of the Marquis de Sade, held in the Bastille until the week before it was stormed, these included a wardrobe stocked with shirts, silk breeches, dressing gowns, hats, coats and boots, and a library of 133 volumes, including Hume's histories and Homer's Iliad. 

Breakfast in the Bastille was served at seven, lunch at eleven, and dinner at six in the evening. The typical menu for the midday repast was soup, an entreé and a meat course of mutton, pork, sausage or veal, washed down with a bottle of wine. Supper consisted of two dishes, one of which was meat, often roast chicken or calf's liver. Seafood options included pike, sole, trout, prawns and even oysters. De Sade was not impressed: "They are clearly starving me to death here," he wrote to his wife Reneé in 1784. He supplemented prison fare by ordering in pâtés, terrines, and jams, as well as the chocolates that he was "accustomed to get from [his] regular shop"; he was provided with fresh flowers every week, and was served strawberries every day. 

- from Fallen Glory, James Crawford, pg. 348

Apr 3, 2024

A form suitable for direct propaganda

 At the novel's conclusion [Zabiba and the King, Saddam Hussein], a people's council debates about what sort of ruler should follow the king. "We do not want our children and ourselves to be under the rule of some madman from among the children or grandchildren of this king, do we?" one representative asks, to laughter and applause. As it deliberates inconclusively, the council goes on to banish a Jewish citizen from the country, celebrate the army, and shower curses on "those who had gained their fortunes at the expense of the people."

Writing became a preoccupation as Saddam spent more time in relative isolation following the near-fatal assassination attempt against Uday. In 1998, Saddam ordered a poet who worked in the press office to tutor him for a month on the rules of poetry. Verse had deep roots and visibility in Iraqi and Arab culture, yet while Saddam did compose some poems, he seemed more attracted to the novel, a form suitable for direct propaganda. (Muammar Qaddafi had published a collection of short stories in 1993, so perhaps Saddam thought his lengthy novels would establish his superior credentials.) Crude and awkward as his allegories were, his writing did offer the private joy of composition, as Saddam worked through creative choices about how to render as literary types the dramatis personae of Baathist Iraq - devilish America, the wayward Kurds, despicable landowners. He weaved these allegorical figures into stories of love and war. Saman Majid came to think of his novel writing as "Saddam's secret garden."

- from The Achilles Trap, Steve Coll, p. 373

Dec 6, 2023

Do You Still Not Understand?

 In Austria, foreign military attachés noticed that the multilingual ideal was rarely attained in practice; theoretically, the men in a Slovenian regiment, for example, would speak Slovenian among themselves but be commanded in German. The troops therefore learned a few dozen phrases in German, but officers in such a regiment were expected to be fluent in Slovenian in order to explain complicated matters and build esprit de corps with their men. In reality, the largely German officer corps would lean hard on cheat sheets like Military Slovenian: A Handbook, which contained useful phrases including "Shut your mouth," "Don't speak unless spoken to," "Wait for me in my office," "No smoking in the stables," and "Do you still not understand?"

- from A Mad Catastrophe: The Outbreak of World War I and the Collapse of the Habsburg Empire, Geoffrey Wawro, 34-35

Jul 31, 2022

Rhangabes

 The big guns opened up on 6 May...soon another portion of wall fell in. At about 7 o'clock at night, with the customary din, a massive assault was launched at the breach. Thousands of men crossed the ditch and ran for the breach...Guistiniani rushed to meet the intruders and a desperate hand-to-hand struggle took place in the gap.

In the first wave, a Janissary called Murat led the assault, slashing fiercely at Guistiniani, who was only saved from death by a Greek jumping down from the wall and cutting off his assailant's legs with an axe. A second wave was led by one Omar Bey, the standard bearer of the European army - and was met by a substantial contingent of Greeks commanded by their officer Rhangabes. In the slashing, hacking confusion, the two leaders squared up to each other in single combat in front of their men. Omar 'bared his sword, he attacked him and with fury they did slash at each other. Rhangabes stepped on a rock, grasped his sword with two hands, struck him on the shoulder, and cut him into two, for he had great strength in his arms.' Infuriated at the death of their commander, the Ottoman troops encircled Rhangabes and cut him down. Like a scene from the Iliad, the two sides surged forward to try to seize the body. The Greeks were desperate to gain control of the corpse and piled out of the gates, 'but they were unable and suffered many losses.' The Ottomans cut the mutilated body in pieces and drove the Greek soldiers back into the city. For three hours the battle raged on but the defenders successfully held the line. As the fighting died down, the cannon started to open up again to prevent the breach being filled and the Ottomans launched a second diversionary raid, trying to set fire to the gate near the palace. This was again defeated. In the darkness Guistiniani and the exhausted defenders worked to rebuild the makeshift defences. Because of the firing at the wall, they were forced to build their protective barrier of earth and timber slightly inside its original line. The wall was holding - but only just. And inside the city 'there was great mourning and dread among the Greeks over Rhangabes, because he was a great warrior, was courageous, and was beloved of the Emperor.'

- Constantinople: The Last Great Siege, Roger Crowley

Dec 23, 2020

Plus ca change

 Whereas so much of the terminology of medieval history and criticism is the invention of the eighteenth century, the terminology of troubadour poetry is wholly contemporary. The worldly, witty, and self-conscious verse was discussed and evaluated by its practitioners and their circles. Poets wrote verses criticizing and satirizing each other and theorizing about their own poetry. Literary controversy developed, with songs exchanged like challenges. Should poetry be clear and accessible, easy to understand, and social in nature (trobar leu), as in the verses of Bernart de Ventadorn and Raimon de Miraval, or should it be personal, allusive, and difficult, making use of colored words with overtones and nuances, like the poetry of Arnaut Daniel (trobar clus)? Macabru boasted that he had written poems he himself could not understand.

- from The Knight in History, 56. 

Mar 26, 2020

Cher Ami

The Meuse-Argonne campaign would be the war's biggest American battle. ... Early in the battle, Major Charles Whittlesey of the U.S. Seventy-seventh Division and more than five hundred men, trapped in a ravine behind enemy lines, were surrounded by a much larger force of Germans. For two days, the Americans fought off the enemy troops. On the second day, their food ran out. Then they were hit by an American artillery barrage intended for the Germans.

Private Omer Richards had carried into battle a cage holding eight carrier pigeons, birds trained to carry messages between specific locations. Several birds, dispatched with messages asking for help, had been shot down. By now there was just one bird left - a favorite named Cher Ami, French for "Dear Friend." Richards clipped a message to the pigeon's left leg, giving the Americans' location: "We are along the road parallel to 276.4. Our own artillery is dropping a barrage on us. For heaven's sake, stop it!"

Cher Ami flew off through a blizzard of enemy bullets and exploding shells. The bird reached his loft, twenty-five miles to the rear, just twenty-five minutes later. He had been shot through the breast and blinded in one eye. But he had delivered the message clipped to his leg, which also had been hit by a bullet and was dangling by a tendon. The shelling was immediately halted.

Nothing else was heard from the beleaguered Americans, who had become known to the world as the Lost Battalion. In an effort to rescue them, two divisions moved out toward the German lines, and as they approached, the Germans withdrew. On October 7, and after a five-day siege, the 194 survivors of the Lost Battalion's 554 men climbed out of their ravine and marched back to the American lines.

Cher Ami lost his shattered leg, but army medics carved a small wooden leg for him. The French awarded the doughty little pigeon their Croix de Guerre medal for bravery under fire. And he was sent to the United States to become an army mascot.

- from The War to End All Wars: World War I by Russell Freedman

Feb 26, 2020

Jury of his peers

"He could not have been tried by a jury of his peers, because his peers did not exist."

- Henry David Thoreau on John Brown

It was a serpent...

Few creatures excite such a mixture of awe, fear, and fascination as snakes. And few are the subject of so many myths and folk beliefs. One of the oldest is that it was a "snake" in the Garden of Eden which was responsible, in John Milton's words, for bringing "death into the world, and all our woe." But there is no reference to a snake in Genesis; it is, rather, a "serpent" that tempted Eve. Serpents, in antiquity, were not necessarily snakes; any creeping thing, especially if venomous or noxious, was called a serpent. In the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, the term was applied to a variety of creatures, including both salamanders and crocodiles. Admittedly, the temptation of Eve by a crocodile does seem to verge on the ridiculous...

- from The Dictionary of Misinformation, Tom Burnam

Jan 19, 2020

Daring, villainous and unmerciful.

It was soon after [this] that Thomas Blood, a self-styled colonel, made his extraordinary and almost successful attempt to steal the crown jewels. Blood was a notorious desperado whose grandfather, an English army officer, had settled in Ireland where he had been elected Member of Parliament for Ennis. Thomas was born in Ireland in about 1618 and, through his father's influence, had become a Justice of the Peace at the age of twenty-one. During the Civil War between Parliament and the royalists he had, with characteristic opportunism, fought first on one side, then on the other. Contriving somehow to be on the winning side when the war was over, he was rewarded with confiscated royalist lands. In 1650 Blood married the daughter of a well-to-do Lancashire landowner, and his future seemed happily assured. But at the restoration of King Charles II in 1660 his estates, in turn, were confiscated by the Court of Claims, and embittered and penniless, as he put it himself, he embarked upon the life of an adventurer. It was a life he was never afterward to abandon.

In 1663 Blood was implicated in a daring plot to seize Dublin Castle. After the plot's failure, he escaped from the authorities and roamed about Ireland in a variety of disguises before settling down in Holland and then in England, where he succeeded in passing himself off as a doctor. In 1670 he and some companions made an unsuccessful attempt to kidnap and hold for ransom the Duke of Ormond, the Lord High Steward. But having failed to retrieve his fortunes this way, he conceived an even more daring crime - the theft of the crown jewels.

At that time the crown jewels were kept in a cupboard behind a wired grille in the basement of the Martin Tower. They were in the custody of the Assistant Keeper of the Jewels, Talbot Edwards, an ex-soldier of seventy-six who lived with his wife and daughter on the upper floors of the Martin Tower. Since his meager salary was so often in arrears, Edwards had sought and obtained permission from Gilbert Talbot, Keeper of the Jewels, to show the collection to visitors for a fee.

One day in April 1671 an aged, bearded clergyman in the robes of a doctor of divinity came to the Tower and asked if he and his wife, an equally ancient lady, could see the crown jewels. Granted permission to do so, the couple was conducted to the Martin Tower where the old lady, upon sight of such valuable and mystical regalia, was seized with "a qualm upon her stomach." She prevailed upon Mr. Edwards to fetch her a glass of spirits. This was provided by Mrs. Edwards, who invited the clergyman's wife to her own private apartments where she could lie down and recover her strength upon a bed. The invitation was accepted; and when the lady and her husband departed some time later, they expressed themselves as being "very thankful for this civility."

Wishing to express his thanks in a more generous manner, the clergyman returned to the Tower a few days later with a present of several pairs of white gloves for Mrs. Edwards. These were accepted with delighted gratitude, and the clergyman was asked to call again whenever he felt so inclined.

The next time he did so he made some flattering remarks about Mrs. Edwards's daughter, such a "pretty gentlewoman"; and he mentioned that he had a nephew about her age, a young man with a handsome income of some two or three hundred pounds a year in land. "If your daughter be free," he added, "and you approve of it, I will bring him hither to see her, and we will endeavor to make it a match!"

Delighted by the prospect of so wealthy a son-in-law, Mrs. Edwards asked the clergyman to dinner. He accepted readily, said grace with deep piety, and offered up a prayer for the king and queen and all the royal family. After dinner, Edwards conducted his guest through the Martin Tower, pointing out its most notable antiquities. During the tour the clergyman expressed his admiration of a case of pistols: they were just the very article to serve as a present for a young nobleman of his acquaintance, if Edwards could be persuaded to part with them for a consideration. Edwards readily agreed. And so, having arranged to return to the Tower with his nephew at seven o'clock on the morning on May 9, the clergyman departed.

Dressed once again in his clerical attire, his unprepossessing features disguised as before by a false white beard, Colonel Blood - for, of course, it was he - arrived at the Tower on the ninth. Blood was accompanied by his son, to act the part of the nephew, and by two others, introduced as friends of his who had a strong curiosity to see the crown jewels. All four men carried walking sticks with rapier blades concealed in the shafts, and all had daggers and pistols in their pockets.

His wife was on her way, Blood told Edwards, suggesting that they wait for her arrival before going upstairs to the ladies. In the meantime, perhaps his friends might see the jewels? Edwards was happy to oblige and conducted them downstairs. The young man remained outside; and Miss Edwards, dressed in her best clothes and excitedly looking down upon him from her upstairs window, supposed that he must be the young nephew, her intended bridegroom.

No sooner had Edwards reached the bottom of the steps that led down into the cellar than a cloak was thrown over his head and a gag pushed into his mouth: "a great plug of wood, with a small hole in the middle to take breath at, was tied on with a waxed leather which went round his neck. At the same time they fastened an iron hook to his nose that no sound might pass from him that way."

The conspirators told Edwards that no harm would come to him if he stayed quiet, but the brave old man refused to submit. He struggled to free himself and made as much noise as he could. His assailants gave him a few "unkind knocks" on the head with a wooden mallet until he fell to the ground, where he continued to struggle until one of the men stabbed him in the belly. "There," his attacker said, kneeling down beside his head and listening for the sounds of breathing, "he is dead, I will warrant him."

The three men then set about breaking into the cupboard where the jewels were kept. Blood got out a crown and stamped on it so that it could be more conveniently concealed under his cloak; one of the others picked up an orb and pushed it down his baggy breeches; the third put the Black Prince's ruby into his pocket and began to file a scepter in two.

Just at that moment Edwards's son arrived unexpectedly at the door of the Martin Tower. He had been abroad in the army for several years and was now on leave. Blood's son attempted to delay the young solider at the door, but since this was his family's home he could not reasonably be prevented from entering it and going upstairs to see his mother and sister. As soon as he was out of sight, young Blood rushed down to warn his father what had happened.

The colonel and his accomplices emerges from the Martin Tower with the pieces of the regalia they had so far managed to steal from the cupboard hidden under their clothes. Walking as quickly as they dared,  but not running for fear of arousing suspicion, they passed by the White Tower, then went through the gateway of the Bloody Tower and along the outer ward toward the Byward Tower. Before they had reached the Byward tower, however, there were loud shouts behind them.

Edwards's son, having greeted his mother and sister, had gone downstairs to see his father whom he had discovered on the floor of the Jewel House, still alive but lying in a pool of blood. The alarm had been given and the pursuit began. The yeoman on guard at the gateway of the Byward Tower attempted to stop the four by-then running men with his halberd, but Blood let fly at him with his pistol and, followed by the others, raced out along the causeway toward the Middle Tower.

Instead of seeking safety by escaping through the Middle Tower, however, Blood and one of his accomplices turned to the left, jumped down onto Tower Wharf and pushed their way through the crowds along the river front. Shouting "stop thief" at the tops of their voices, they pointed to their pursuers as the villains. For a few moments it seemed that they might escape in the confusion they succeeded in causing, but they were soon overpowered and thrown into the dungeons, where their two companions shortly joined them. The benign old clergyman was seen to be, in fact, a beardless, tall, "rough-boned man, with small legs, a pock-frecken face with little hollow blue eyes." His features were "daring, villainous and unmerciful."

A pearl and a diamond had fallen out of their settings in the crown during "the robustious struggle." But both they and the Black Prince's ruby were eventually recovered and returned to the custody of Talbot Edwards, whose stalwart behavior was rewarded by a grant of 200 pounds. So delayed was the payment, however, that Edwards was obliged to sell his right to receive it at a discount of 50 per cent in order to pay his doctor's bill. He died soon afterward.

Colonel Blood fared much better. The king, intrigued by accounts of his exploit, wanted to meet the famous rogue. At the interview, Charles was evidently much taken with the colonel's outrageous charm and impudence, his disarming rascality; for Blood was not merely pardoned, but his lands were restored to him together with a pension of 500 pounds a year.

Such munificence naturally led to rumors that the king had all along been in league with Blood, that sorely pressed for money, he had proposed the theft to Blood so that the two of them might share the proceeds. Others held that the king, when drunk, had laid a bet that the crown jewels would be stolen and had put up Blood in order to win his wager for him. The truth was more prosaic. In return for his freedom, his lands, and his pension, the ingenious and daring colonel was to act as a spy for the government and the court, to spread rumors in the city when required to do so, and to inform against republicans and would-be traitors. He evidently found the bargain a satisfactory one, for a few days after it was concluded an acquaintance found Colonel Blood strutting about on Tower Green wearing a handsome new suit and periwig, "exceeding pleasant and jocose."

- from The Tower of London, Christopher Hibbert

Apr 20, 2019

No misnomer

Gentleman in wigs and satin knee-britches composing philosophical tracts - the Founding Fathers (and their equally quaintly bedecked spouses) little resemble the 20th-century image of revolutionaries: Lenin atop a cannon rallying the sailors at Kronstadt, or Mao in peasant garb haranguing the troops on the Long March. But the American Revolution was no misnomer. It irreparably shattered the twin pillars of tradition: monarchical authority and hereditary privilege; it revivified an ancient experiment in democracy, conferring political form on a fractious people; and it loosened the bonds of society, giving free rein to acquisitive, religious, and reforming energies. More than its topographical constituents - mountains and farmlands, forests and towns - the new nation was an amalgam of ideas, extracted from classical Greece and Rome, from the Old and New Testaments, from peasant culture and Enlightenment philosophy, fused in the heat of war and invasion, and then poured, white hot, over much of North America, whose borders it eventually overspilled.

- from Mapping America's Past, pg. 60

Apr 18, 2019

From Asimov

- Admiral Sir Cloudesley Shovel, commander-in-chief of the British fleet, was murdered in 1707 by an old woman as he struggled ashore after the loss of his ship on the rocks of the Scilly Islands. She killed him in the belief, current at the time among coastal inhabitants, that a body washed up was a derelict, thus giving her legal possession of the emerald ring on the admiral's finger.

- The American paleontologist Edward Cope (1840 - 97), whose large collection of fossil mammals is at the American Museum of Natural History, in New York, was a Quaker and consequently refused to carry a gun during his U.S. Western expeditions, despite the very real danger from Indians. He once flabbergasted hostile Indians surrounding him by removing his false teeth and putting them back, over and over. The Indians let him go.

- Ben Franklin wanted the turkey, not the eagle, to be the U.S. national symbol. He considered the eagle "a bird of bad moral character" because it lives "by sharping and robbing."

- Cyprus was one of the world's important mining centers in ancient times, but for reasons still unknown the Romans halted operations there and sealed the tunnels. Many of the tunnels were found and reopened in this century, thanks to clever detective work by an American mining engineer, D.A. Gunther. In the New York Public Library, he had happened to find an ancient account of the mines. Years of ingenious search in Cyprus led him to the tunnels, which he found complete with usable support timbers and oil lamps. Cyprus became an important mining center again.

- A well-intentioned philanthropist, Eugene Scheifflin, instituted a project in the 1890s to bring to America all the birds mentioned by Shakespeare. Unfortunately, Hotspur talks about the starling in Henry IV, Part I; starlings were therefore let loose in New York's Central Park. The noisy nuisances now number in the millions from Alaska to Mexico, and they will be with us for as long as the plays of Shakespeare. Maybe longer.

- from Isaac Asimov's Book of Facts

Dec 8, 2018

an afternoon to read

US policymakers reacted in shock over what they denounced as Japan's unprovoked attack [on Pearl Harbor]. For being so starkly surprised, however, they had no one to blame but themselves. Had they taken an afternoon to read Thucydides and to think about the consequences of Athen's Megarian Decree, or reflect on Britain's efforts to contain the rise of Germany in the decade after 1914, they could have better anticipated Japan's initiative...

- Graham Allison, Destined For War

The only lesson

Like other practicing historians, I am often asked what the "lessons of history" are. I answer that the only lesson I have learnt from studying the past is that there are no permanent winners and losers.

- Ramachandra Guha

Aug 13, 2018

The peculiarity of the whole affair was its needlessness

The peculiarity of the whole affair was its needlessness, and this underlines two characteristics of folly: it often does not spring from a great design, and its consequences are frequently a suprise. The folly lies in persisting thereafter. With acute if unwitting significance, a French historian wrote of the Revocation that "Great designs are rare in politics; the King proceeded empirically and sometimes impulsively." His point is reinforced from an unexpected source in a perceptive comment by Ralph Waldo Emerson, who cautioned, "In analyzing history do not be too profound, for often the causes are quite superficial." This is a factor usually overlooked by political scientists who, in discussing the nature of power, always treat it, even when negatively, with immense respect. They fail to see it as sometimes a matter of ordinary men walking into water over their heads, acting unwisely or foolishly or perversely as people in ordinary circumstances frequently do. The trappings and impact of power deceive us, endowing the possessors with a quality larger than life. Shorn of his tremendous curled peruke, high heels and ermine, the Sun King was a man subject to misjudgment, error and impulse - like you and me.

- Barbara Tuchman, The March of Folly. 

Jul 30, 2018

A cheering section

Women have very rarely engaged in combat, but have often played auxiliary roles in mobilization and logistics. Before hostilities commenced, they might shame cowards, taunt the hesitant, and participate in dances of incitement. Among some groups, women have accompanied war parties to carry weapons and food. During combat, they might serve as a cheering section, supply first aid, or collect spent enemy missiles to resupply their own warriors....

from War Before Civilization, Lawrence Keeley, 35.

Jul 12, 2018

Wise leeches

Last-minute negotiations having failed to avert conflict, the battle [of Shrewsbury] began about midday on 21 July 1403 with a hail of arrows from the veteran bowmen of the prince's own county palatine of Cheshire. Unfortunately for him, they had taken the rebel side and he was on the receiving end. As the royal army struggled up the slope, the Welsh and Cheshire archers drew 'so fast that...the sun which at that time was bright and clear then lost its brightness so thick were the arrows' and Henry's men fell 'as fast as leaves fall in autumn after the hoar-frost'. An arrow struck the sixteen-year-old prince full in the face but he refused to withdraw, fearing the effect it would have on his men. Instead he led the fierce hand-to-hand fighting that continued until nightfall...

A way had to be found of extracting the arrow that had entered his face on the left side of his nose. The shaft was successfully removed but the arrowhead remained embedded six inches deep in the bone at the back of his skull. Various 'wise leeches' or doctors were consulted and advised 'drinks and other cures', all of which failed. In the end it was the king's surgeon, a convicted (but pardoned) coiner of false money, John Bradmore, who saved the prince and the day. He devised a small pair of hollow tongs the width of the arrow-head with a screw-like thread at the end of each arm and a separate screw mechanism running through the centre. The wound had to be enlarged and deepened before the tongs could be inserted and this was done by means of series of increasingly large and long probes...When Bradmore judged that he had reached the bottom of the wound he introduced the tongs at the same angle as the arrow had entered, placed the screw in the centre and manouevred the instrument into the socket of the arrowhead. 'The, by moving it to and fro, little by little (with the help of God) I extracted the arrowhead.' ...

The pain the prince must have suffered in the course of this lengthy operation is unimaginable...

- from Agincourt by Juliet Barker

May 29, 2018

It is not difficult to imagine

It is not difficult to imagine how this scenario [war with North Korea] could come to pass. ... Imagine that Kim and Trump arrive at the summit only to discover that they hold radically different views of the commitment to "denuclearize": Trump believes that Kim is willing to negotiate away his arsenal for sanctions relief, whereas Kim believes that full denuclearization also requires the removal of U.S. troops from the Korean Peninsula and and end to the U.S.-South Korean alliance... . After it becomes clear that Trump will not move forward on Kim's terms, Kim is outraged and renews his August 2017 pledge to test missiles over Guam.

Both Washington and Pyongyang now think the other is responsible for derailing diplomacy. Out of a desire to induce the United States to drop its denuclearization demands, Kim decides to show that his willingness to negotiate does not mean his will has been broken, and he proceeds with his missile launch. Much as the Japanese did before they attacked Pearl Harbor, he hopes that a missile test over Guam - a U.S. territory but not a state - will unnerve the United States enough to persuade it to accept his nuclear program, but not so much as to bring a full-scale war.

But then, one of his missiles expels debris over Guam. Fragments from the reentry vehicle strike the island itself, killing a few residents - who are, after all, U.S. citizens. Trump declares this "an act of war" and gives Kim 48 hours to issue a formal apology and a pledge to denuclearize. Kim does not comply, and the United States dusts off one of its plans for a limited military strike. It attacks a known missile storage facility, believing the limited nature of the target will induce Kim's cooperation and minimize the risk of retaliation. Instead, Kim views the strike as the beginning of a larger effort to disarm him and as a prelude to regime change. Following his conventional bombardment of Seoul, the United States begins to attack other known weapons sites and command-and-control facilities to neutralize the threat. Kim launches nuclear weapons the following day.

- from "Perception and Misperception on the Korean Peninsula," Robert Jervis and Mira Rapp-Hooper, in Foreign Affairs, May/June 2018, pg. 116

Sep 28, 2017

Literary history is an artifice

We envisage the literature of every century as a corpus of works grouped around a core of classics; and we derive our notion of the classics from our professors, who took it from their professors, who got it from theirs, and so on, back to some disappearing point in the early nineteenth century. Literary history is an artifice, pieced together over many generations, shortened here and lengthened there, worn thin in some places, patched over in others, and laced through everywhere with anachronism. It bears little relation to the actual experience of literature in the past.

- from The Forbidden Best-sellers of Pre-Revolutionary France, Robert Darnton

Sep 4, 2017

While in intense dental agony

Cavities ...[were] one of humankind's oldest miseries. Terrified of tooth extraction, people often suffered intense and chronic pain - and many of these people were history's major policymakers. It is surprising that history books omit the fact that, for instance, Louis XIV and Elizabeth I (to mention only two policy-shaping figures) often had to render major decisions while in intense dental agony. Louis, in 1685, signed the revocation of the Edict of Nantes (which had granted religious freedom), causing thousands to emigrate, while he was in the throes of a month-long tooth infection. It had developed into a raw, unhealing opening between the roof of his mouth and his sinuses.

Elizabeth, on the other hand, suffered chronically from deep, massive cavities but feared the misery of extraction. In December 1578, an unrelenting tooth pain kept her awake day and night for two weeks, necessitating drugs that were themselves heavily disorientating. ... Throughout the weeks of misery, she had continued to oversee legislation that affected the lives of millions of subjects.

... A volume of speculative history could be written on the effects of severe and protracted dental pain on policy-making.

- from the endlessly quotable Extraordinary Origins of Everyday Things, Charles Panati, 212.