Jul 13, 2013

"Why ought people do what morality requires? The honest answer, I think, is that they ought to do it only if they care about the well-being of others; wish to live in harmony with them; want to avoid a life likely to be solitary, nasty, brutish, and short; are moved by examples of good lives; and are repelled by examples of evil ones. Such people are the friends of humanity. Humanity also has its enemies, and that is what evildoers indifferent to the moral "ought" are. It is important to bear in mind that evildoers are not mere backsliders who lie, steal, or cheat, but people whose actions cause monstrous harm. They do not just violate moral limits, but reveal a depraved attitude toward them. They are the sort of people who snatch an old woman from her deathbed in order to burn her alive, like the crusaders; who enjoy a cozy lunch between two bouts of mass murder, like Stangl; and who incite a mob to dismember and cannibalize live victims on mere suspicion of political dissent, like Robespierre. To think of such evildoers as enemies of humanity is not too strong a condemnation and to treat them as such is well deserved. ..."

- from John Kekes' (2005) The Roots of Evil, Cornell University Press, pg. 198. A well-argued book, sobering, clear-sighted and unromantic, although perhaps Kekes pays too little heed to  psychopathy as a disease. Not least among the book's virtues is simply being a university-press book that is actually readable.

Jun 1, 2013

For information sake

"...Aretino's dialogues are of additional literary interest for serving as the model for such works as L'Escole des Filles (1655), which appeared in English as The School of Venus (1688). It was the French version of this "novel" - consisting mainly of a discussion of sexual matters by two girls, Fanchon and Susanne - that was purchased on February 8, 1668, by His Majesty' Secretary of Naval Affairs, one Samuel Pepys. He characterized it as "the most bawdy, lewd book that I ever saw," and for this reason procured it "in plain binding, avoiding the buying of it better bound because I resolve, as soon as I have read it, to burn it." The next night, after consuming "a mighty good store of wine," he retreated to the privacy of his chamber, where he read the book "for information sake," then proceeded with the burning, "that it might not be among my books to my shame."

- from Hugh Rawson's enormously diverting Wicked Words. 


"[On the eve of the battle of Stones River], both commanders formed similar plans for the morrow: to turn the enemy's right, get into his rear, and cut him off from his base. As the two armies bedded down a few hundred yards from each other, their bands commenced a musical battle as prelude to the real thing next day. Northern musicians blared out "Yankee Doodle" and "Hail Columbia," and were answered across the way by "Dixie" and "The Bonnie Blue Flag." One band finally swung into the sentimental strains of "Home Sweet Home"; others picked it up and soon thousands of Yanks and Rebs who tomorrow would kill each other were singing the familiar words together."

- James McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom, pg. 580.

Almost 25,000 soldiers were killed, injured, or taken prisoner in the battle of Stones River, Dec. 31 1862 - Jan. 2, 1863.

Apr 16, 2013

A dissent

I recently watched the new movie "The Master" and was totally underwhelmed. Instead of insight into the dismal cult of scientology, American culture, or science fiction, we get a succession of archly significant scenes that neither deepens the one-dimensional characters nor furthers the little plot that exists. This movie contains all the usual gaucheries of contemporary film-making: gratuitous nudity, a confusion of yelling and profanity with dialogue, an inability to say anything concisely, a heavy-handed approach to theme, and overblown, sententious acting. Save your money.

GRADE: D-